I was in a coaching session recently with a brilliant scientist-turned-executive. He was describing a recurring pattern he kept falling into during disagreements at work.
“I know I should ask more questions,” he said. “I know I should stay curious. BUt the minute someone challenges my recommendation, I can feel myself gearing up to defend it.”
He paused for a moment and laughed a little.
“Then afterward, I realize I did it again – slipped into defender mode as if it was 25 years ago and I was back in front of a panel defending my work.”
If you’ve ever walked out of a meeting replaying your reactions in your head and knowing you didn’t show up the way you wanted to, you’re not alone. Most leaders I work with already know what good leadership looks like. They’ve read the books, attended the trainings, and understand the concepts intellectually. The challenge usually isn’t knowledge – it’s what happens under pressure.
This month, we’re continuing the Good Power Formula™ series with the second element: Mindset. If Vision is about knowing where you want to go, Mindset is about understanding the internal cognitive patterns that shape how you respond when the stakes are high. Because leadership is rarely tested when things feel calm and easy. It’s tested in the moments when you feel challenged, uncertain, overloaded, or exposed.
The Leadership Patterns Running Beneath the Surface
When people hear the word “mindset,” they often think about positive thinking or growth mindset theory. Those ideas matter, but leadership mindset runs much deeper than that.
Mindset is the complex set of beliefs, assumptions, and narratives about yourself, others, and how the world works. Some were installed early in your life. Some you adopted from leaders you admired or leaders you survived. They’ve been running in the background ever since, like an operating system you didn’t choose but that shapes how you respond to challenges, what risks you take, what decisions you make and, ultimately, what you achieve.
In a recent session with my own coach, we uncovered a mindset pattern that has been running for me for as long as I can remember:
Feel pressure > Work Harder > Prove Value.
At a subconscious level, the belief running the show is that in order to stay safe I need to always show up with competence, always be reliable, and in the words of the old Dry Idea deodorant commercial, “Never Let ‘Em See Me Sweat”. In other words, I have to be effortlessly perfect.
I know this pattern well. It has helped me accomplish meaningful things throughout my life and career. It has also pushed me toward over-functioning, taking on too much responsibility, and believing that the answer to pressure is always more effort.
Maybe this mindset is one that’s familiar to you, or maybe yours looks different. Here are some examples of patterns that I see often in the people I work with when they are under pressure:
- If I don’t stay on top of everything, things will fall apart.
- It’s easier to do it myself than trust someone to do it right.
- I need to anticipate every possible problem before moving forward.
- Asking for help makes me look weak or unprepared.
- I need to manage everyone else’s emotions.
I could go on and on, but you’re probably getting the idea. And here’s the thing, all of these beliefs are at least partly or sometimes true. It’s not that they’re wrong, but when we decide that they are absolute, immutable truths, we get ourselves into trouble.
Most of these patterns began as intelligent adaptations. At some point, they helped us succeed, stay safe, gain approval, or survive difficult environments. The challenge is that leadership eventually asks us to examine whether the very strategies that once helped us succeed are now limiting our effectiveness, relationships, or capacity to lead sustainably.
Why Can’t I Shift My Mindset When It Matters Most?
One of the most frustrating experiences for leaders is knowing exactly what they want to do differently and still struggling to do it in the moment. This gap between knowing and doing shows up everywhere:
- You know you should delegate more, but you keep pulling work back because “it’s faster if I just do it.”
- You know you want to listen with curiosity, but you find yourself defending your position before the other person has finished speaking.
- You know you should pause before reacting, but your body (or mouth) reacts before your thinking brain catches up.
Why does this happen?
Because mindset isn’t just cognitive. It’s wired into identity. Your nervous system, your sense of safety, your definition of what it means to be competent or valuable as a leader all activate faster than conscious thought. Neuroscience research on habit formation and identity shows us that the brain prioritizes efficiency over accuracy. When faced with ambiguity or threat, we default to what’s familiar, not necessarily what’s effective.
That’s why leadership growth often feels less like learning something new and more like interrupting something old.
I see this frequently with highly capable leaders who have built successful careers around expertise and reliability. The very behaviors that helped them rise, such as being exceptionally brilliant, solving problems quickly, carrying more than others, or having the right answers, can become limiting at more senior levels of leadership. It’s not because those qualities are bad. It’s because leadership eventually asks something different from us, which requires less proving, and more presence.
The Shift From Proving to Presence
One of the most powerful shifts I see in high-achieving leaders is the move from proving to presence.
Proving is rooted in the belief that your value is about performing, knowing more, working harder, and demonstrating competence at every turn. When you’re operating from proving, you’re defensive when challenged, reluctant to admit uncertainty, and constantly scanning for threats to your credibility.
Presence is the mindset that says your value comes from clarity, from creating space for others’ perspectives, from staying grounded under pressure. It’s rooted in the belief that leadership is about creating conditions for good decisions, not making every decision yourself. When you’re operating from presence, you can hold uncertainty without performing confidence. You can be challenged without being threatened. You can lead without needing to be the smartest person in the room.
This connects directly back to how I defined The Good Power Formula™ in the introductory post:
Directing your resources with integrity, empathy, and humility
to create outcomes that reflect your deepest values,
while honoring the humanity of those who see things differently.
The Good Power Formula™ is intentional, aligned, and sustainable. When you’re operating from a “proving” mindset, you’re reactive, performative, and exhausting yourself. When you shift to presence, you become more intentional, your actions align with your values, and you conserve energy for what actually matters.
In my work with leaders through The Good Power Formula™ , we work on surfacing the beliefs running their leadership and decide which ones still serve them. This isn’t about positive thinking or affirmations. It’s about becoming conscious of the operating system so you can make different choices in real time.
A Simple Question That Changes Things
One of the most powerful mindset practices I use with clients is surprisingly simple.
When you notice yourself digging in, overworking, over-explaining, rescuing, controlling, or reacting defensively, pause and ask yourself:
“At what cost?”
- At what cost am I holding this position so tightly?
- At what cost am I continuing to operate this way?
- What am I protecting right now?
- What might become possible if I responded differently?
A senior leader I worked with recently realized she was exhausting herself trying to maintain control over every detail of her team’s work. Her intention was good. She cared deeply about quality and outcomes.
But when she paused long enough to ask herself, “At what cost?” the answer became painfully clear. Her team had stopped taking initiative, cross-functional relationships were strained and she was carrying responsibility that no longer needed to belong entirely to her.
That question created enough space for her to begin experimenting with a different way of leading. It wasn’t perfect or instantaneous, but it was the first step in conscious movement toward a different way of leading.
The Invitation
Mindset work is not about becoming a completely different person. It’s about becoming more aware of the patterns already shaping your leadership so you have more choice in how you respond.
The goal is not perfection, the goal is more presence, awareness, intentionality, and ability to stay connected to your values and your vision when pressure rises. Because leadership is not only built through strategy, intelligence, or effort, it’s built through the capacity to notice what’s running beneath the surface — and to choose how you want to lead from there.
Next month in The Good Power Formula™ series, we’ll look at Skill Set — the practical leadership capabilities that help leaders navigate complexity, influence effectively, and lead at scale without losing themselves in the process.





